Playing: Results.mp3 KBPS: 128 | kHz: 44

Silent Hill (1999)

>>> WELCOME TO MY HOMEPAGE. BEST VIEWED IN NETSCAPE NAVIGATOR 4.0 <<<
"James... You made me happy."

THE SILENT HILL MOVIES ARE SEXIST

When I originally watched the Silent Hill movie adaptation (2006) for the first time in Fall 2020, I had an initially positive takeaway. The set piece was good, the casting for Cybil felt amazingly accurate, and the music was taken straight from the game, but officially scored for cinema. All in all, a fun experience. My friend and I had finished playing the game and went straight to the movie to experience and review it. Sure, they unnecessarily changed Cheryl's name to "Sharon," and our main protagonist, Cheryl's father Harry, became Sharon's mother Rose.

And, surely, that isn't a big deal?

But six years have passed, I've replayed and re-experienced Silent Hill for the PS1 in a new light, especially with the second game and movie in mind.

And I now see the movies for what they are.

Not only are they terrible, but they're terribly sexist too.


"I get it now... Why I'm still alive even though everyone else's dead."

PORTRAYAL OF MASCULINITY IN FATHER FIGURES

Harry Mason portrays what would stereotypically be labeled as "feminine/motherly" tendencies despite being a man/Cheryl's father. I argue that this is a very good thing and contrasts beautifully to other, more typical father-figure portrayals, like that of Joel Miller (The Last of Us Part I) and Kratos (God of War). Like with nearly everything related to humankind, fatherhood is a range. How we, as people, express ourselves throughout our various different social roles in life is a range.

Off the bat, Harry Mason seems kind. When he wakes up in Silent Hill and meets the cop Cybil, who is wary of him since he's the only other person she's been able to find in town, he speaks gently. Despite having lost his daughter, he is not outwardly panicked or angry. He gets to the point and does so calmly: "Have you seen a little girl? Just turned seven last month... Short, black hair... My daughter." And when Cybil eventually informs Harry that it's dangerous outside and tries to stop him from leaving their sanctuary, he says: "I need to find her now! Cheryl's my little girl. I can't just leave her out there by herself."

Sure, the dialogue is slightly stilted and sometimes awkward, most likely due to lack of direction for voice actors and maybe slightly rough translation, but the point gets across well.

When Harry meets a seemingly unhinged lady in the Balkan church who mentions "the girl," Harry aptly responds: "You know something? Tell me!" But he never goes beyond his shouted demands. Harry does not threaten violence to get answers or point his gun at people to get them to talk. He acts like a normal person in an abnormal situation, and - refreshingly - there's no hypermasculine act on display.

My favorite thing about Harry is how realistically insistent he is on finding Cheryl. Anytime he meets someone new, he asks right away. Even when Kauffman shoots at him, Harry does not meet him with violence. He simply asks: "Have you seen a little girl anywhere? I'm looking for my daughter. She's only seven. Short, black hair." And when Kauffman has nothing helpful to say and only implies that she might be dead, Harry does not get angry. He only lets out a dejected sigh, like he'd been realistically thinking it, too.

And when Harry meets the fan-favorite Lisa Garland, he once again asks: "Let me ask you, have you seen a little girl around here? Short, black hair. Seven years old."

And when he meets up with Cybil in the Antique Shop: "What about my daughter? Did you see her?" If it's not the first Harry brings up in a conversation, it's the second. I'll stop beating this horse, now. I just wanted to express how realistic Harry is in the grand scheme of things, and how nice his simple lack of over-aggression (that is often attributed to men on screen) is.


SPOILERS

Finally, Harry is afraid.

In the infamous reveal that Lisa Garland was dead all along, and her body starts to decompose right before our eyes, she begs Harry to stay with her as her body catches up to her death. And in a very human moment, Harry runs. In a regretful and sad, but ultimately understandable choice, Harry flees the room and barricades the door behind him, listening to Lisa cry and try to reach him as she slowly turns into one of the monsters that's been hunting Harry throughout the hospital.

I like Harry Mason. He's a wonderful portrayal of a father, and it's an absolute shame that the director of the movie, Christophe Gans, felt the need to change him to a womanbecause he, seemingly, wasn't "tough enough" to be a man.

"I'm not your Mary."

THE AUTONOMY OF A WOMAN

Don't watch the Return to Silent Hill movie that came out this year (2026); the one based on the second game. It's just bad. Unsurprisingly, it's direcyed by Gans (again) and it's worse in every way imaginable. I present to the court, my evidence:

Without going into the story of Silent Hill 2 too much, I'd like to lay a somewhat solid groundwork of what the game is actually about. Spoilers ahead. Also, the story has practically nothing to do with the first game so, if at any point you feel like the second game would be more "up your alley," I recommend you just hop on over to it and read this later.

In Silent Hill 2, you play as James Sunderland. You travel to Silent Hill after recieving a letter from your wife, Mary, who's been dead for, like, three years or something. Like two minutes into the game, you meet a woman named Angela, who immediately seems somewhat weary of James, and she directs you to the town.

At some poit, you also meet a little girl named Laura (who locks James in a room with a monster, lol). And then, eventually you meet a woman who bears a striking resemblance to your wife: Maria.

In Silent Hill 2, all of these women/girls are different characters. They're their own being. They have thoughts and feelings and a story that's entirely their own. Angela, who carries with her a tragic history of abuse, has been brought to Silent Hill for reasons related to the deaths of her abusers: her father and brother. Laura, who seemingly see no monsters, is a striking reminder of innocence. Maria, literally born from a wish, continues to die before James' eyes, over and over again, in grotesque ways. And finally Mary, betrayed by the person who was supposed to be by her side, through sickness and health.

So, I don't know why Gans felt the need, in the movie adaptation of this game, to make all the women secretly one woman, revealed at the end at the sight of gravestone bearing the name: "Mary Maria Angela Laura Crane." Yes. It's as fucking stupid as it sounds.

Here's my final spoiler warning.


James Sunderland is the villain of Silent Hill 2. It's a story so infamous and haunting that, if this is the first place you're hearing it, I'm honestly surprised.

In the game, revealed at the end, James was the one to kill a terminally-ill Mary Sunderland, by smothering her with a pillow. Suddenly, Maria's presence makes a lot more sense now. And why the monsters look the way they do...

Mary does not ask James to kill her. In audio that was ultimately cut from the final version of the game, the audience can hear her cries as James ends her life.

So, in the biggest L of the century, why Gans felt the need to change this ending to exonerate James, I'll never know. In the movie, we are unfortunately granted a scene in which Mary asks James to kill her, in order to end her suffering. And then James gets a "second chance" with Mary through some time travel loop thing or something (don't know, don't care, don't like).

In total, the women (and girl) of Silent Hill 2 are Marymalgamated into a device to prop up James' character, and make him the hero that he never fucking was.

"The Fear Of Blood Tends To Create Fear For The Flesh"

CONCLUSION

Silent Hill (2001) has great representation of both female and male characters, with interesting female and male villains and victims. Dahlia and Lisa are both ends of the spectrum, with Dahlia being cruel and Lisa kind. Harry and Kauffman provide the same contrast.

Finally, Lisa successfully enacts her revenge in a violent way (that I argue is typically associated with male characters). On the other hand, Harry accepts the role of parent to a new infant he will eventually name Heather, while suffering the loss of his daughter Cheryl (who, while reincarnated somewhat into Heather has still been lost to Harry). Basically, the "feminine" and "masculine" roles here are reversed: Lisa violently drags Kauffman to hell, preventing him from escaping the town - while Harry, though surviving the incident, must continue his life and role as a parent, but now accompanied by a newfound grief through the loss of his adopted daughter.