Playing: Endless Zero (Remix).mp3 KBPS: 128 | kHz: 44

Haunting Ground (2005)

>>> Precious, precious, princess. Precious, precious, precious, precious, precious...<<<
"I am not complete."

I Can Do It, You Can Do It: Haunting Ground and Material Horror

I bought Haunting Ground off of Mercari in September 2023. The anticipation of its arrival was electric. When I opened the package, I saw it in all its glory, all its imperfections. The plastic case is a bit dingy, but the black and white cover is most beautiful in person. The manual was almost perfect, with a slight dent in the side, and no writing in the “notes” section. The disc, however, was thoroughly scratched. When in the light, you could see the hundreds of miniature lines, thin as strands of hair. I'm sure there was awe and reverence in my gaze when I first held this object in my hands. But there's a weight that comes with the ownership of this game. This weight does not fall physically in my hands, like when I hold the case, but on my spiritual shoulders. Why did I want this game so badly, and what does it mean to actually own it?

This discomfort only grows as you explore the world of Haunting Ground, and it's history. It is not just a horror game, but an embodiment of what I call material horror, a critique that emerges when horror's thematic violences are mirrored by the real, obscured, systems of production and circulation of an object. By examining Haunting Ground both as a form of media and as a commodity, I will explore how horror becomes embedded in narrative, gameplay, and the very medium and matter through which the first two reach us. My analysis includes firsthand observation of the physical game disc, case, and manual. I draw upon sensory engagement through the actual playing (use) of the game. Finally, I do secondary research on materials, manufacturing, and theory and I reference scholarly work on material culture. My work is grounded in a feminist media critique informed by material culture studies.


"The essence of life..."

WHAT IS HAUNTING GROUND?

Haunting Ground is a 2005 horror game developed by Capcom and released for the PlayStation 2 on April 21st in Japan. The player controls Fiona, an eighteen-year-old art student who wakes up in a cage after a car crash. She's been kidnapped by a relative and brought to a castle she is now heir to, although she doesn't find this out until much later. The gameplay consists of hiding from stalker enemies and commanding Hewie, your white German Shepherd, for assistance.

Our female lead Fiona is unathletic and mostly helpless. She trips over herself and faints more than once throughout the game. She has basic offensive moves of her own: kicking and shoving. These, however, do not inflict much damage. The stalker enemies also cannot be permanently defeated until their boss fight, which directly involves Hewie's aid. From the beginning of the game, the player is clearly instructed that they cannot fight their way out of this castle alone.

Fiona's main pursuers need her Azoth (an unexplained life force simply described in-game as the “essence of life”) to be “reborn,” which requires Fiona's body. This is exactly how it sounds, which culminates in the true horror of this game: trying to not only keep your life, but endure the constant threats around you that directly mirrors the real-life struggles of women who must navigate their environment and find ways to protect themselves from harassment and abuse.

"Where is you?"

GAMEPLAY

The physical engagement of the player with the game - my hands wrapped around the handles of the controller, the pads of my fingers upon the buttons and the clickiness of their response, the vibration feedback that mimics a heartbeat, and the actual controlling of Fiona's movements - becomes an important space for discussing material horror. This is where the materiality of play intersects with the thematic contents of the game; I am controlling Fiona's avatar in a way Fiona's pursuers could only dream of. While viewing it this way makes it rather horrific, I have to make peace with it to continue my experience with the game. Is this wrong to do?

"My dolly!"

PRODUCTION

Haunting Ground was created to scare; to entertain through fear. The game's physical form, though, holds a more profound type of horror; one rooted in the global systems that birthed it. In reference to a North American version, a copy of the game includes a polycarbonate plastic DVD, a polypropylene or polystyrene case, and a paper manual.3 These materials are byproducts of crude oil refining, and are tied to petroleum extraction. These activities often cause pollution, health issues, and environmental harm, especially for the communities near the refineries and chemical plants. The people impacted by the process are often not involved in the process itself.

Capcom, like many other video game companies, doesn't disclose its manufacturing process. However, it's likely that most of the materials were sourced globally, with plastics coming from countries such as China, Taiwan, and South Korea. The discs were probably pressed in the U.S., Canada, or Mexico through companies like Sony DADC or Technicolor potentially in charge of handling production. Packaging was either assembled through automated or semi-automated processes overlooked by humans, which involves blue-collar labor. In these cases, the workers typically live near the production site. If it was made in Mexico, it would've been due to lower labor costs and how close Mexico is to the U.S.

After manufacture, the game would've traveled from factory to warehouse, and then to retail. If it traveled across oceans, it would've done so by cargo ship. If it traveled on land, it would've done so by truck or train. I can't keep track of the hypothetical number of hands involved in the making of this game. It would've been passed along to dozens of people: technicians, factory workers, truck drivers, retail staff, and consumers. This labor typically remains invisible to the consumer, what Arjun Appadurai refers to as “commodity fetishism.”

"That, my dear, is what you will become in the future."

MATERIAL HORROR

My copy arrived on my doorstep eighteen years after its initial release. I bought it on Mercari, a second-hand online marketplace, soon after receiving my first paycheck from my then-new job. It wasn't a celebratory purchase; it was a comfort brought to me by financial stability. I purchased my copy for roughly $300 to $350. This was the price for a complete copy: a case, manual, and functional (although used) disc. Anything less would've cost less. A sealed copy would've cost significantly more. I just wanted to hold the object and open the case, to look upon it and put the disc in the game console.

After carefully opening the package, I immediately ran upstairs to play the game for roughly half an hour, accompanied by my older brother. The game would take me two years to finally sit down and beat. I don't play it often, but it holds symbolic weight in my life. I connect to it more through ownership than frequent use. However, I do “use” it as part of my personality. It is a piece of me, as it makes up a part of my hobbies.

The case opens and shuts with distinct, satisfying clicking sounds. The art on the cover shows Fiona with an ambiguous expression – she is not distressed, but more hopeful; her face open. Hewie's face appears beside her, solidifying that the two are a duo; inseparable. My copy of the manual is untouched, and I have not written in it. Truly, I have a perverse desire to preserve the value of this game, despite never intending to part with it. I didn't want to claim it, like how Fiona's many pursuers want to claim her. However, I do believe that, as I get older, and the reality of death becomes clearer, I will write in the manual to, selfishly, keep a part of myself with the game forever. At the end of the day, I will always want it to be mine so badly.

For the purpose of this analysis, I'd like to try and explain this game as a commodity by proposing a new term: material horror. It is a framework for studying commodities that looks not only into the story and representation of an object, but the physical, economic, and cultural life itself. It avoids commodity fetishism by bringing to light the process in which its “self” was made. It falls away from traditional criticism of horror by focusing on the ways in which horror is embedded in the objects, through their production, circulation, preservation, and the powers at play that they reveal or conceal. Miller argues that objects carry affective and historical weight; they embody emotion, memory, and social meaning.6 Latour's Actor-Network Theory (ANT) introduces the concept of both humans and nonhumans as “actants,” both having agency within a network. Objects participate just as much in shaping the social as people do.

“All those technical strategies, especially art...., which human beings employ in order to secure the acquiescence of other people in their intentions or projects”. Gell's idea of Technology of Enchantment consists of strategies people use to influence others to convince or persuade them to go along with what they want or support their goals. While I've already briefly described the way in which Haunting Ground has agency through the theoretical frameworks of other authors, I would like to expand on this theory. I'd also like to propose evidence in support of the separation of intent between the people behind the game and the game itself. I propose that Haunting Ground has the agency to influence others to care about its ideology. Although humans try to gather and lead others under the umbrella of a cause, Haunting Ground transcends this and garners its own influence beyond the intent of the creator. Through this interpretation of the Technology of Enchantment, the game becomes a stage and Fiona becomes the star. Despite being fictional, she becomes the one to influence the player. The atmosphere, music, and design all come into play to emotionally entangle you in the story and experience. Using Pink's Sensory Ethnography,9 I see the cord of the remote as a wire that connects Fiona's heartbeat to mine. The game's intent is for ours to be in sync. The intent is for everything to be in sync, eventually. My commands to Hewie will line up with perfect precision by the end of the game. As Fiona is chased, her heart will beat through the grasp of my palms as the game sends timed vibrations through the remote, symbolic of her life in my hands. My heart is intended to race alongside hers, as the chase music begins. It crescendos to a forte as the stalker gets closer, the staccato beats growing faster to accentuate the pounding in my chest. Fiona and I are one. But I am also a witness, looking in through a peephole of a screen, like some of Fiona's many voyeuristic pursuers in-game.

When I play this game, I am connected to Fiona through various tricks the game and PlayStation 2 use in tandem to scare me. I am not thinking of whom the director is. I am not thinking of the creators of the game. I am not thinking about the environmental pollution the making of this game caused. This is not to take credit away from the creators, but to observe Haunting Ground in a new, analytical way. It is also done with the intent to critique.

I critique the creators and separate their intent versus the intent of the game itself by suggesting that various factors in the game appeal to a male audience. For example, two of the additional costumes for Fiona overly sexualize her without a purpose in the story. They are called “Illegal in Some States” and “Texas Cowgirl.” In addition to this, Hewie was added as a companion because enough people at Capcom thought that a female protagonist alone would not be marketable to consumers (men).10 These two examples show that, although this game has been a hit with women like myself and influenced us by providing an immersive and fascinating portrayal of the female experience, the intent behind Capcom was always to sell the game to men and to put men in the shoes of women. It was never written for the woman herself. This is another horrific truth that this game embodies: it was born to be sold. It was born to appeal to men. It was born to be objectified. These are the very themes that it, itself, explores the terrors of.

My final piece of evidence for this stance comes from the manual of the game. It goes as follows:


“A message from the creator of HAUNTING GROUND. This game is overflowing with fear and terror. As you play, you'll be chased into desperation by strange things. It's up to you to be brave and guide Fiona through it. I want you to protect her, and rescue her. There are some truly unspeakable and unimaginable horrors awaiting you, but I have faith in you. You can do it.”

While I agree that, mechanically, Fiona is powerless, she actually holds most of the influence over the player – which, within itself, is power. As a woman living in the United States, the fight for bodily autonomy is scary to endure. Despite feeling unable to verbalize my experience as a woman under the current presidency of 2025, I can state that my place as a woman in this world has impacted my relationship with this game, and vice versa. To paraphrase my mother: “I never knew I had those rights until they were taken away.” When Roe v Wade was overturned, I made connections to Haunting Ground and turned those into humor as a way to cope. Three years later, when Executive Order 14253 passed, I was hit with an overwhelming sense of hopelessness, despite most of it not having any direct relation to women's rights. This made me reconnect to the game in a new, more mature way. I'm significantly less scared to play this game now than I was as a teenager, but never have I felt more pained to play it. It's like a deep ache of realization that this game, made twenty years ago, sees me more than other people do. Sees me more than some men do.

"Thanks, Hewie."

CONCLUSION

The words in the manual say, “it's up to you to be brave and guide Fiona through it,” but it's really up to both of us. Before my play experience, I saw Fiona as a character. After my play experience, I saw her as a symbol.

Haunting Ground remains in my collection, and I still haven't written in the manual. At times, I take it off the shelf just to hold it. It's weight in my hands is like an embrace. At other times, I show it off, talk about it. I don't often let it speak for itself. By bringing into light the materiality of horror – the game's packaging, its price, its physicality – we open up new paths for thinking and discussion over what it means to consume, collect, and critique media. Horror isn't contained within the game and displayed only through the screen; it's in the object itself. And now, it's in me, too.

When I read the phrases “you can do it” and “I have faith in you” from the manual, I do not hear it from Kazuhiro Tsuchiya, the director of the game. I hear the words directly from Fiona herself. She's made it through the castle and escaped those who tried to harm her. Hewie, the direct embodiment of hope, is at her side. I can do it, too. You can do it, too.