MY DESPERATE PLEA FOR YOU TO PLAY FATAL FRAME (2001) BECAUSE IT'S REALLY FUN AND THE STORY IS COOL
For the best analysis of Fatal Frame (2001), especially of gender representation of women, I turn reader's to a Master's Degree Project, written by Vanja Waller in 2021. It's aptly titled GENDER REPRESENTATION THROUGH THE HORRORS OF FATAL FRAME (2001): Textual Analysis into female gender representation in the Japanese survival horror game, Fatal Frame(2001).
It could be considered a long read, consisting of 87 pages in the PDF document, but I think it's worth every minute - especially if you're familiar or a fan of the Fatal Frame series. I will try my best to do a thorough analysis that is more than a cheap imitation of this thesis, but no promises :)
Of course, ideas from the thesis will be directly credited.
One of my favorite things about the survival horror genre is the depiction of love despite dire circumstances and hope in the face of evil. Being brave while simultaenously being afraid. Our protagonist, Miku, encompasses all of this in the first entry to the Fatal Frame series.
I'm quite fond of the familiar horror trope of "going to a new place in search of somebody." Ethan Winters going to Dulvey, Louisiana to pick up his wife, Mia. Leon S. Kennedy travelling to Valdelobos to locate Ashley Graham.
Beyond this, I am always happy to see the depiction of faith in and dedication among siblings, even when it becomes somewhat twisted. Claire Redfield, a nineteen-year-old college student, entering a zombie infested Raccoon City in search of her brother, Chris. Mio looking after Mayu throughout the entirety of Fatal Frame II and the village curse being entwined with their twinhood. Henry, taking his own life after Sam turns, feeling responsible for his little brother's infection.
With four siblings of my own, the depiction of siblinghood in survival horror is where I "see myself the most" in the characters I either play as or interact with. It's one of my favorite narratives to hop into because I truly don't think there is anything that I wouldn't do for my siblings. Solo-ing a haunted mansion at night? I mean, I wouldn't be happy about it (and probably would die early on), but I'd do it.
The first examples that come to mind are sister's sacrificing something for a sibling or in search for their brother, and I honestly really like that. Women and girls often times take on a heavy burden with little to no complaint, and I like the representation of bravery in the Fatal Frame series.
With every entry starring a lead woman or girl, Fatal Frame is the purest depiction of "doing it scared is just as brave." Courage is not the absence of fear, but simply the acknowledgement that something is more important than that fear - In Miku's case, Mafuyu is more important than every threatening ghost in that mansion.
A different thing to note in the case of the first game is the simultaenous victim and villain representation of Kirie, our exonerated antagonist. For more about this, I will redirect readers to the previously mentioned master's thesis, as Waller does a fantastic job of breaking down the role of women in horror media. Here is a snippet:
Moving into the main antagonist of the game, Kirie Himuro, as mentioned her story could be considered more complex in comparison to what is shown and not shown in Miku’s story. In contrast to Miku, Kirie shows to have a tragic past and an emotional journey through it as well, which already gives her character more depth. Both Kirie Himuro and the Blinded Maiden can be considered good examples of characters which, through their visual in-game representation, intrigue the audience’s interest in mystery and the grotesque. As respondents mentioned through the online survey, the antagonists were more well-liked than the protagonist, due to the amount of intrigue they contribute to the game experience. They expressed that the antagonists, through their body-horror, reflects their individual rituals and that the mystery around their deaths help create an interesting mixture of feelings in the player made out of fear, horror, and empathy. As discussed previously in Horror film theory on gender usage on different roles, the masculine being the monster or hero and the feminine being the victim, the female antagonist of Fatal Frame still uphold a certain identity as Japanese women, as they are mostly seen wearing their traditional outfits. However, their bodies are broken which still gives them a victimized appearance, even though they are meant to play the part as the monster.
And here's a bit more than a snippet from the same author:
Finally, to return to the main research question of this study: “How do culture and cinematic practices of narrative and visuals represent female characters in the Japanese survival horror game, Fatal Frame (2001)?” The over-arching conclusion is that the female characters of Fatal Frame (2001), while having major roles in the narrative and maintaining their femininity, are still victimized to varying degrees no matter the role they play, by both cultural- and cinematic practices. This can be seen in the levels of body-horror shown on the female ghosts compared to the male ones and the usage of femininity as a victim-label commonly seen in the Horror genre. The cultural aspects of Japanese horror are very pronounced in the game and there are no clear signs of the game or narrative differing from what can already be found in Japanese horror film. Fatal Frame follows the Japanese horror narrative accurately by using archetypes and narratives previously seen in Japanese horror film, which in turn shape the presentation of the characters in the game. There is the overbearing sense of the Ie system, judging Kirie Himuro’s personal feelings conflicting with her duty and shows that salvation can only be gained by staying true to one’s social obligations. The mono-no-aware, flowing throughout and showing characters maintain a calm acceptance towards their own fate, no matter how unjust it may seem. The main antagonist both represents the archetypes of the “tragic lovers” and “vengeful ghost”, as she has a history of being a virtuous woman, abused and tortured by the choices made by a malicious man and (in this case) several other men, which results in an unjust death that brings her back to life for vengeance. As for the cinematic practices, the camera angles and positions are used to frequently place different characters in vulnerable viewpoints, no matter their role or gender. It could be argued, however, that there is a higher focus throughout the game on female characters, being quite pronounced as either the main protagonist, main antagonist, and several other female antagonists with prominent bodyhorror designs. A possible exceptions to this being Mafuyu Hinasaki and Kogi Ogata, who are the only male characters shown vulnerable or killed, but it can still be argued that female characters are more pronounced with detailed scenes descripting their deaths compared to such male characters. The cinematic cutscenes show Miku Hinasaki in ominous surroundings with a possible danger observing her through the perspective of the camera or detailed visions of the past where female characters are either vulnerable, killed, or tortured. Also, the cameras within gameplay are also fixed and angled in ways where Miku, or the player, is surprised by sudden ghosts or watched by ghosts from above.
Ultimately, this article is simply intended to get readers to play Fatal Frame. However, if you're not able to or don't want to physically play it, but still want to experience the story, I recommend Gab Smolder's Let's Play, available on YouTube. As a Japanese speaker and someone with a university-level education on Japanese culture, she gives great insight not only to environmental set pieces but translation differences from the game's English and Japanese versions.